≡ Menu

Book Review and Response: Peter Carmichael

Kevin Levin June 6, 2006 1 comment

H-South has posted a review of Peter Carmichael’s The Last Generation: Young Virginians in Peace, War, and Reunion by Robert Tinkler. Read Carmichael’s response to Tinkler followed by Tinkler’s response to Carmichael.

1 comment… add one

John Maass  June 7, 2006, 6:52 am

Thank you, this is quite valuable to have the links in one place! JM

Reply

Previous Post: Ken Burns

Next Post: Dimitri’s Imaginary Lost Cause

Your Voice

Confederacy Theory (2)
- Evan Kutzler { It is dangerous for me to follow your links from twitter. I never return quickly... }
- Corey Meyer { I see lots of familiar faces and the same old arguments }
Solomon Northup: Farmer (13)
- Bryan Cheeseboro { Hi Kevin, There's been some questions about the historical accuracy of how the film depicts... }
How Not To Respond To a Review by Ted Savas and Stephen Hood (41)
- Patrick Young { In terms of bias in reviewing this book, I addressed it in my amazon post:... }
- Pat Young { When Adam Badeau wrote that my opinion should be "questioned as indicating a bias against... }
- Butler King { Mr. King. Why do you and Adam Badeau have the same ISP address? Perhaps it's... }
- Patrick Young { My sarcasm was directed at you. I have never seen you or spoken to you... }
Older »

Share this Post