Angel of Marye’s Heights by Mort Kunstler
Note: For additional commentary, check out Tim Abbott’s post on Kirkland at Walking the Berkshires.
Civil War Memory
Reflections of a High School History Teacher & Civil War Historian
Subscribe to Civil War Memory
Recent Posts
- A Pension For a Vote
- Mac Wycoff on Richard Kirkland
- The National Park Service’s Black Confederates
- John Tenniel’s Black Confederate
- Civil Warriors
- Ann DeWitt Responds (well, sort of)
- What Does Your Classroom’s Seating Arrangement Reflect?
- “Ground Zero,” Civil War Memory, and Contested Landscapes
- “Hurrah! for Massa Linkum”
- Digging for the Truth
Popular Posts
-
The Future of the Confederate Flag
My recent post on the unveiling of another large Confederate flag in Tennessee generated a number of comments. It’s an emotional issue on all sides and it is unlikely that the interested parties will ever fully agree on whether it should be displayed in public as well as its meaning. But that’s the way it
75 Comments — 13812 Views — June 11, 2009
-
Is the Richard Kirkland Story True?
The following guest post by Michael Schaffner examines the wartime evidence for the Kirkland story. It is a thoroughly researched essay and is well worth your time. I should point out that Mr. Schaffner did not set out to write a piece debunking this particular story. Like many of us he was curious about the
38 Comments — 7816 Views — December 22, 2009
-
Nat Turner Lived 40 Miles From the Crater
I‘ve been thinking quite a bit about the images of slave rebellions and miscegenation that shaped the world view of white Southerners throughout the antebellum period. In the case of Nat Turner’s Rebellion newspapers throughout Virginia and beyond offered extensive coverage and attempted to offer an explanation that would assuage the concerns of what white
17 Comments — 7363 Views — June 26, 2009
-
Family Fun With Abraham Lincoln and John Wilkes Booth
[Hat-Tip to Steve West] How would you like to attend a reenactment of Abraham Lincoln’s assassination. On March 7 the Sovereign Majestic Theater in Pottsville, Pennsylvania will be transformed into Ford’s Theater. Booth will be played by Charles Sacavage, a retired Pottsville Area School District history teacher who now teaches history part-time at Alvernia
18 Comments — 6840 Views — February 25, 2009
-
Patrick Cleburne and Black Confederates Take Hollywood
[Hat-Tip to Lee White] Back in 2008 I commented on a graphic novel that tells the story of Patrick Cleburne’s plan to arm slaves in exchange for their freedom. I expressed a number of concerns in that post and I appreciate the author of the novel for offering his own perspective. Now it looks like that
75 Comments — 5663 Views — February 5, 2010
Random Posts
-
Museum of the Confederacy and NAACP Working Together?
This is a promising development. Many of you are aware that the Museum of the Confederacy hopes to spread its wings in the coming years as a way of getting out from under the shadow and construction cranes around the VCU Medical Center. This will involve moving its collection to four different locations in time
6 Comments — 70 Views — March 11, 2008
-
Cell Phones in Cafes
I own a cell phone, but most of the time I can’t tell you where it is and I honestly cannot remember the number. You see, I hate talking on the phone, but more importantly, the idea of using it in a public space such as a cafe is absolutely abhorrent to me. So, here
9 Comments — 63 Views — March 21, 2008
-
Is This Appropriate?
It wasn't too long ago that reenactments were considered to be divisive and illegitimate as a form of remembrance. In fact, the Civil War Centennial pushed to keep them out of commemorations of important battles after the embarrassment at First Manassas in 1961. Since the 1970s, however, reenacting has become the most popular form
2 Comments — 126 Views — September 23, 2008
-
A Statement To My Readers
I wanted to take a few minutes to respond to the comments to my recent post, Jacksonian Paternalism in the Extreme that accuse me of being both anti-South and anti-Christian. You can read the comments on your own. Now I imagine that most of my regular readers see through these comments as a reflection of
5 Comments — 89 Views — October 9, 2006
-
The Best Jobs in the U.S.
I don’t need to be told by some independent source that I have an awesome job. Still, it doesn’t hurt to have it confirmed. 1. Mathematician 2. Actuary 3. Statistician 4. Biologist 5. Software Engineer 6. Computer Systems Analyst 7. Historian 8. Sociologist 9. Industrial Designer 10. Accountant. Tweet
1 Comments — 127 Views — January 8, 2009
Recent Comments
- Andy Hall: Meant to have a big block quote in the middle of that.
- Dick Stanley: Well, of course they’d be upset about Obamacare, etc. They’re conservatives, by definition. Albeit a rather unusual...
- Andy Hall: Dunno, but parents who home-school are absolutely the intended audience. From the advertisement:There is no question that the youth of...
- Corey Meyer: I wonder what the % of kids there are homeschooled? Sorry if this bring your buddy Richard Williams into this discussion.
- Kevin Levin: You are absolutely right.
- Andy Hall: Amen. I’d only add, though, that I’m increasingly convinced that among the hard-core Southern Heritage™ types, it’s...
- Kevin Levin: I am not surprised at all by the results of that survey. Somehow we’ve been seduced into thinking that our students understand...
- Ken Noe: Professor Guelzo: Thanks from me too for joining the conversation. I wouldn’t say that I’m entirely hopeful about digital...
- Allen C. Guelzo: I’m drawing a distinction between retreival and learning along lines parallel to the kid in our classes who knows what the...
- Kevin Levin: Professor Guelzo, Glad to see that you’ve found your way to Civil War Memory and thanks for following up with this comment....
Archives
Copyright © 2010 · Genesis Theme Framework by StudioPress · WordPress · Log in
How does this stack up against Armistead's Freemason exchange? Is the latter better documented? Just wondering….
Can't say since I don't know much about Armistead's Freemason Exchange. I'm beginning to think that this has much in common with Bill Marvel's analysis of the famous salute that supposedly took place at Appomattox. Enjoy the holidays.
This makes me wonder whether there been a scholarly treatment of the various accounts of Masons giving aid and comfort to enemy members of their fraternity stricken on the field? Armistead, etc.? That is another pervasive theme in the brother vs. brother story line. Maybe I will take a blog level stab at it…
Interesting that the previous comment was along these same lines. I sense a meme…
That would indeed make for an interesting post. I just don't know much of anything about this to comment on it. Enjoy the holidays, Tim.
Michael Halleran's book on this topic is due out in the spring. The blurb in the Alabama catalog specifically mentions Armistead. (hat tip to Drew Wagenhoffer):
http://uapress.ua.edu/product/Better-Angels-of-...
Thanks for the reference, Ken. I shared a taxi at the Southern with a Rep. from UA Press. I need to see about getting a review copy of this.
Happy Holidays to you and Nancy.
Same to you and Michaela.
By the way, to answer your original question, I'm hardly an expert, and reliance on an 1880 account will always worry me, but the Schaffner and Wycoff posts dialectically have established to my satisfaction anyway that the core of the story probably is true. Somebody went over the wall once ["the Georgian"], it probably was indeed Kirkland [because 24th GA vets or other Carolinians would have claimed the honor otherwise, as vets were wont to do by the 1880s], and then in the decades that followed Kershaw typically added details he thought he remembered as he moved himself to the center of the story. The long truce portion of the tale isn't so problematic to me–adrenalin notoriously warps one's sense of the passage of time, and measurements of time are notoriously the least reliable portion of battle accounts. Like Mac Wycoff, I wouldn't expect to find anything in the OR either–in 1862, especially after the sack of Fredericksburg, rescuing Yankees was hardly praiseworthy.
To me, the more interesting story from Marye's Heights anyway has always been the notion that Tom Cobb's own men fragged him, the father of the Confederate constitution.
Thanks for the comment, Ken. It's also clear to me that somebody went over that wall, but I am not ready to say that it was Kirkland. I am hoping that Mac follows up his initial comment. It would be interesting to know whether Kershaw's is the earliest account. What concerns me is that most of the post-1880 accounts seem to follow Kershaw's analysis much too closely to count as independent corroboration.
Anyway, I am much more interested in why we find this story so compelling. I may try to write up a short article on all of this at some point.
On the one hand, probably not. It's a warm-fuzzy-feelgood and Mort by-God Kunstler painted it and that's good enough for me! It says something about how we *want* humanity to be even in the midst of war and suffering.
On the other hand, well, yes. We need to know if it is, in fact just one more myth of the Lost Cause: Noble Confederate Selflessly Aids Damn Yankees. And also, apparently, Kunstler's Kirkland found time to bathe before aiding them. I can't believe I clicked over to a bigger version of it to confirm that.
I can cite one of example of this battlefield Masonic “consideration” happening, and at Fredericksburg, no less. I've extensively researched the short life of Charles M. Hamilton, a Florida “carpetbagger” Congressman during Reconstruction, for an article that appeared in the Florida Historical Quarterly a few years ago. Hamilton, a soldier in Co. A of the 5th PA Reserves, was shot in the leg at Fredericksburg when charging the Confederate lines. According to an 1868 campaign biographical sketch in a Florida newspaper, “The moment after he fell he was about to be bayoneted, but discovering a Masonic badge upon one of the enemy, he gave the “sign” and was saved.” [Tallahassee Weekly Floridian, March 10, 1868] Hamilton was then taken prisoner and sent to Libby Prison. Hamilton was a very forthright and honest individual, almost guileless. I can't imagine the motivation for him, or the author of the article, inventing the Masonic incident 5+ years later.