How Many Americans Are Interested in the Civil War?

Of course, it is an absurd question, but apparently the producer and writer of the upcoming TV mini-series, “To Appomattox” wants to know.  An email circular is going around to Civil War round tables and reenacting groups to try to gauge the number so as to guarantee a financial return.  I commented on this series a few weeks ago, but this program is shaping up to be a real doozy.

First off, if you are making a movie or mini-series to appeal to Civil War buffs it is going to suck big time.  If we ever do get a chance to see it we can rest assured that a sufficient number of Americans are still interested in the Civil War. :-)

26 responses... add one

HBO usually does quality work when they do historical dramas. But you are right, if the producers are trying to appeal to certain groups, we’re in trouble.

Carl Edwards, a driver, was slated to play John B. Gordon. Looking at the cast list he is now absent, so who knows what happened.

Also, they’re never going to make us all totally happy. I once was talking to someone who was enraged (I’m not kidding; he was really angry) that the movie “Gettysburg” didn’t include his particular area of interest in the battle. I pointed out that (aside from the fact that it was based on a novel & never was a documentary, as should have been clear to anyone who saw “Sgt. Santa” in the opening scenes) that it was a three day battle that had a great deal happening simultaneously, or nearly so, in each army, in the town, and in the interactions among and between them. As it was, the movie was long enough to need an intermission; even if it was long as the Holocaust documentary “Shoah” (9 hours, 4 minutes), the filmmakers couldn’t have covered everything. No matter what they chose, someone would be ticked off.

If they’re trying to gauge how many Americans are interested in the Civil War by asking round tables and reenacting groups, the figure will be … 100%. This could lead to some unrealistic hopes on the part of the filmmakers.

Well then they better get the movie out ASAP before the roundtable folks completely die off

I’ve read the script and it’s pretty good, aside from a few bonehead errors that they’ve hopefully fixed. There’s even a “memory” episode.

maybe they should look at the box office for the “Lincoln: Vampire Killer” movie… Didn’t it outdraw the “Avengers”??? 8-)

AL:VK has already grossed three quarters of the combined total box office for Gettysburg and G&G, combined, adjusting for inflation. It’s hardly a summer blockbuster, but it will earn its way.

But theatrical feature releases aren’t the right comparison for a production like To Appomattox. What they’re shooting for is a something more akin to Band of Brothers, which attracts a different audience and is entirely different in style and tone.

Andy, I saw your post right after I posted this comment. I should remember to check both your site and Kevin’s before I comment!

I am disappointed that I missed the Lincoln movie in the local theaters. Oh well, that’s why we have Netflix!

I just took a look at the cast and I’m a bit baffled with some of the choices. Gonna have to try and reserve judgement, but it’ll be hard as I laughed out loud at at least two of them.

Yeah, but some of them bear an uncanny resemblance to their historical counterpart. :-)

“AL:VK has already grossed three quarters of the combined total box office for Gettysburg and G&G, combined”
And how do its takings compare with those of other vampire movies? That might be a measure of the CW interest factor.

Kevin,

I have read the entire script for the entire mini-series, and I am satisfied that the history is accurate, and I likewise am convinced that it will be done as accurately as budgetary constraints will permit.

I found some errors during my review and pointed them out, and all have been corrected. The primary writer, Michael Brecker, is very determined to get it right, and has gladly accepted all of the constructive criticism that we have thrown at him. I was very pleasantly surprised when I learned that. It made me very hopeful for the future of this project.

I also want to address the question about the NASCAR connection, as I asked the same question.

I was advised that with many of the NASCAR drivers being Southerners, many of them have a direct ancestral connection to the Civil War, and that many of them–many of whom are bankrolling the project–have gotten involved in an effort to pay tribute to their ancestors. That’s sincere, and it’s hard to argue with it.

Eric, what about the language? So many historical films get the costumes and sets just right (though usually both are too clean), then have the characters speaking the English of our day. In AL:VK, young Abe excuses himself after walking in on two people having sex with “Sorry, my bad.”

Join the Conversation