Lieutenant Freeman S. Bowley’s Crater

wilson-honor_in_commandOne of the most interesting Union accounts of the Crater is Lieutenant Freeman Bowley’s memoir, which was published in the National Tribune between April 1899 and September 1899.  [In 2006 Keith Wilson published these articles as Honor in Command.]  Bowley served in the 30th USCT from May 1864 till his capture at the Crater on July 30, 1864.  Bowley’s memoir is valuable for a number of reasons.  His memory is clearly intact and offers vivid descriptions of battle and life as a prisoner in Columbia, South Carolina.  In reference to the Crater it provides a detailed account of his capture and the threats he faced as an officer in a “colored regiment” both in Petersburg and while a prisoner.  Unlike some of his fellow officers who worried about the repercussions from leading blacks into battle, Bowley refused to hide his rank and unit.  There are a number of passages that are worth referencing, but I am going to confine myself to a few that bear on my previous post.

Some of the most interesting passages illustrate his interactions with civilians, particularly women.  One woman, who sold Bowley some dumplings following his capture at the Crater said the following: “‘Yo’ Yanks is all a miserable lyin’ set of thieves, come down yere to steal we’uns niggers.  If I was a man I’d git a gun and shoot ye dead; I’d git a sword and chop yer to pieces.'”  Once out of Petersburg the prisoners were shipped by rail to Danville where they stayed for a short period.  A group of citizens met the train and were outraged at the site of black soldiers and their “abolitionist allies”:

A crowd of citizens gathered around the depot.  The sight of negroes among the prisoners excited them greatly.  Cries of “Kill them! Hang the nigger!” resounded on all sides.  Two officers were pointed out as being officers of colored regiments.  The mob howled with fury and some one brought a rope.  The two officers, Lieut. Shell [Shull], 28th USCT, and Lieut. Dowling [Downing], 31st USCT were dragged from the car, and it seemed as though they were to be hanged then and there.

Luckily the men were not executed, but the rage expressed that day must be understood as the desire to see the leaders of a slave rebellion executed rather than simply as retribution against a hated enemy.  A few weeks later while being imprisoned in Columbia, South Carolina Bowley had another experience with a white Southern woman:

Visitors “to see the Yankees” were an almost everyday occurrence, and the guards never failed to designate me as “That thar little Yankee cuss is an officer in a nigger regiment.”  I had never made any retort, until one day a woman made the remark, “He ‘un had orter be hung for makin’ the niggers fight we ‘uns,” when I turned and said, “Yes, madam; I am an officer of a nigger regiment and I am proud of it.  The time will come when the blackest nigger who wears blue will be a better man than any rebel who ever wore gray!”  The woman flushed, furious with anger.  “If I had my way, I’d kill all you Yankees who came down here to fight we ‘uns and steal we ‘uns niggers–niggers we brung up jes’ like our own children–an teach ’em to fight we ‘uns,” she said.

I think we should not lose sight of the fact that Bowley’s recollection of this woman’s response comes roughly thirty years after the war; however, we should note that it fits perfectly within the paternal mindset of white Southerners who viewed their slaves as family and who believed that discontent and outright rebellion must be understood as external.  Bowley and other USCT officers continued to worry about their status and safety throughout this period.  They wondered specifically as to whether Confederate authorities would enforce an act that stipulated that any white officers captured on the field of battle leading black soldiers would be treated “as inciting servile insurrection.”  Within the framework of a slave rebellion this act of the Confederate Congress does not seem like such a radical turn.  In fact, it fits neatly into long-standing assumptions surrounding what to do with those who would incite complacent slaves against their caring masters.  Bowley witnessed it first hand.

Searching for Black Confederates: The Civil War’s Most Persistent Myth

“Levin’s study is the first of its kind to blueprint and then debunk the mythology of enslaved African Americans who allegedly served voluntarily in behalf of the Confederacy.”–Journal of Southern History

Purchase your copy today!

6 comments… add one
  • Albert J. Bowley, Jr. May 16, 2020 @ 11:42

    I am the great grandson of Freeman Sparks Bowley, Captain, 30th US Colored Infantry. His two sons went to West Point retiring as Colonel and Lt General in the US Army. His grandson retired as a Major General, USAF and I retired as a Colonel in the USAF. We were very proud of his service and his book was used to inspire many students at the College for Enlisted Professional Military Education where I was Commander. God bless the Warrior Clan! Albert J. Bowley, Jr., USAF (ret)

  • Mike Jun 19, 2009 @ 16:14

    Sounds like Bowley was a lucky guy to have lived through that mess to tell what happened.

  • David Tatum Jr Jun 19, 2009 @ 16:04


    With all due, respect Racial issuse were not confined to the south.

    Draft Riots 1863
    An excerpt from
    In the Shadow of Slavery:
    African Americans in New York City, 1626-1863
    by Leslie M. Harris

    The rioters’ targets initially included only military and governmental buildings, symbols of the unfairness of the draft. Mobs attacked only those individuals who interfered with their actions. But by afternoon of the first day, some of the rioters had turned to attacks on black people, and on things symbolic of black political, economic, and social power. Rioters attacked a black fruit vendor and a nine-year-old boy at the corner of Broadway and Chambers Street before moving to the Colored Orphan Asylum on Fifth Avenue between Forty-Third and Forty-Fourth Streets. In all, rioters lynched eleven black men over the five days of mayhem. The riots forced hundreds of blacks out of the city.

    Not to disagree sir, just trying to show the whole picture !

    Respectfully Submitted

    David Tatum Jr.

    • Kevin Levin Jun 19, 2009 @ 16:26


      My research is focused on the South which is why I am not discussing the problem of race in the North. That should not be taken as an attempt to make a moral claim about the South or attempting to vindicate the North.

      The Draft Riots were one of the worst racial riots in American history, but it has nothing to do directly with the Crater, which is my subject. It is true that African Americans faced any number of challenges as soldiers in the US Army owing to their color. I do address some of this in my manuscript, but most of it is confined to how white Southerners interpreted and remembered the battle.

  • Kevin Levin Jun 19, 2009 @ 10:44


    I recently reread the Bowley account and after your comment yesterday decided to collect a few references for a post. You are spot on in contrasting his style and focus with Gordon.

  • Timothy Orr Jun 19, 2009 @ 9:53

    Kevin, I’ll second everything you said. Bowley’s memoir is in my list of “top-ten” best Civil War memoirs. It is well-written, lurid, and it describes the brutal side of the war, an aspect often missing from the prolific John B. Gordon-esque memoirists who wrote in the postbellum years.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *